• Home
  • Works
  • Introduction Guide Collaboration Sponsors / Collaborators Copyrights Contact Imprint
Bibliothek der Kirchenväter
Search
DE EN FR
Works Athanasius of Alexandria (295-373) Orationes contra Arianos Four Discourses against the Arians
Discourse II.

32.

It is plain from this that the Arians are not fighting with us about their heresy; but while they pretend us, their real fight is against the Godhead Itself. For if the voice were ours which says, ‘This it My Son 1,’ small were our complaint of them; but if it is the Father’s voice, and the disciples heard it, and the Son too says of Himself, ‘Before all the mountains He begat me 2,’ are they not fighting against God, as the giants 3 in story, having their tongue, as the Psalmist says, a sharp sword 4 for irreligion? For they neither feared the voice of the Father, nor reverenced the Saviour’s words, nor trusted the Saints, one of whom writes, ‘Who being the Brightness of His glory and the Expression of His subsistence,’ and ‘Christ the power of God and the Wisdom of God 5;’ and another says in the Psalm, ‘With Thee is the well of life, and in Thy Light shall we see light,’ and ‘Thou madest all things in Wisdom 6;’ and the Prophets say, ‘And the Word of the Lord came to me 7;’ and John, ‘In the beginning was the Word;’ and Luke, ‘As they delivered them unto us which from the beginning were eye-witnesses and ministers of the Word 8;’ and as David again says, ‘He sent His Word and healed them 9.’ All these passages proscribe in every light the Arian heresy, and signify the eternity of the Word, and that He is not foreign but proper to the Father’s Essence. For when saw any one light without radiance? or who dares to say that the expression can be different from the subsistence? or has not a man himself lost his mind 10 who even entertains the thought that God was ever without Reason and without Wisdom? For such illustrations and such images has Scripture proposed, that, considering the inability of human nature to comprehend God, we might be able to form ideas even from these however poorly and dimly, and as far as is attainable 11. And as the creation contains P. 366 abundant matter for the knowledge of the being of a God and a Providence (‘for by the greatness and beauty of the creatures proportionably the Maker of them is seen 12’) , and we learn from them without asking for voices, but hearing the Scriptures we believe, and surveying the very order and the harmony of all things, we acknowledge that He is Maker and Lord and God of all, and apprehend His marvellous Providence and governance over all things; so in like manner about the Son’s Godhead, what has been above said is sufficient, and it becomes superfluous, or rather it is very mad to dispute about it, or to ask in an heretical way, How can the Son be from eternity? or how can He be from the Father’s Essence, yet not a part? since what is said to be of another, is a part of him; and what is divided, is not whole.


  1. Vid. Matt. xvii. 5 .  ↩

  2. Prov. viii. 25 , LXX.  ↩

  3. τοὺς μυθευομένους γίγαντας , vid.supr. de Decr.fin. Also ὡς τοὺς γίγανταςOrat.iii. 42. InHist. Arian.74. he calls Constantius a γίγας . The same idea is implied in the word θεομάχος so frequently applied to Arianism, as in this sentence.  ↩

  4. Ps. lvii. 4 .  ↩

  5. Heb. i. 3 ; 1 Cor. i. 24 .  ↩

  6. Ps. xxxvi. 9 ; civ. 24.  ↩

  7. Jer. ii. 1 .  ↩

  8. John i. 1 ; Luke i. 2 .  ↩

  9. Ps. cvii. 20 .  ↩

  10. Vid. p. 150, n. 6, alsoGent.40 fin. where what is here, as commonly, applied to the Arians, is, before the rise of Arianism, applied to unbelievers.  ↩

  11. Vid.de Decr.12, 16, notes i. 26, n. 2, ii. 36, n. 1.de Syn.41, n. 1. Inillud Omnia3 fin. vid. also 6. Aug.Confess.xiii. 11. And again,Trin.xv. 39. And S. Basilcontr. Eunom.ii. 17.  ↩

  12. Wisd. xiii. 5 .  ↩

pattern
  Print   Report an error
  • Show the text
  • Bibliographic Reference
  • Scans for this version
Translations of this Work
Four Discourses against the Arians
Vier Reden gegen die Arianer (BKV) Compare
Commentaries for this Work
Einleitung zu den Reden gegen die Arianer (BKV)
Introduction to Four Discourses against the Arians

Contents

Faculty of Theology, Patristics and History of the Early Church
Miséricorde, Av. Europe 20, CH 1700 Fribourg

© 2025 Gregor Emmenegger
Imprint
Privacy policy